I don't have either of the knives you're asking about but thought I'd stir the stew a little. Like Diceman, I like Ontario's Rat knives. I have four of them. I also recently picked up a Swamp Rat M6 that seems to be a good solid piece and it came razor sharp. The M6s are available now at the Swamp Rat shop.

Welcome and good luck.

Mr. Bill Old guys just know stuff! and, Old guys just have old stuff!