This time I voted for the S6. Last time I chose the Dog Father. Since the last poll, I have had several occasions to carry and use the S6. It is not too big and heavy, yet big enough for most jobs. I can carry it discreetly with the kydex sheath leatherface made for me. Since I always carry a pocket knife anyway, I don't want to limit myself to a small fixed blade. But most important of all, the Scrapper 6 feels so right in my hand and has such perfect balance, it inspires confidence. My new RMD does much the same for me, but Rats are not in this poll.