Yeah,... I actually would much rather have the size of the P series with the CR123 batteries and the little extra juice that the CR123 batteries offer, but I conceded that the AA would probably get it done for me and with less ongoing expense and hassle.

Those dang compromises in life again.....

I don't have too much issue with the difference in power. I doubt most people would notice much difference between 175 lumens and 200 lumens.
And an extra 10 - 15 percent run time really doesn't add up to that much to me either. I can carry spare AA batteries easy enough.

I would prefer the size of the P series, but in the end, I considered, the cost and maintenance of the batteries to be the deciding factor (for me). Like I mentioned, I already have a BUNCH of NiMH rechargables and a recharger... so.... AA for me. But, I can see why some people might be inclined to go for the P series - everybody has their own deciding factors.

I was also at a toss up between 1 vs. 2 batteries. I like the smaller size lights for just being able to stick in my pocket or whatever. I reasoned that I could carry a 2nd backup battery if hiking/camping in my pack just as easy as in the light. But, the 2 batteries gives a little more power and unless I missed it somewhere, the P1D did not have the Premium or the tail-clicker option. But, I think I saw that I can order the P1 body tube for $12.00 - giving me more options with the same light. I am assuming I can unscrew and change out to a smaller tube pretty easily.

If you buy the L1 and want the tail clicker cap, it is an extra $6.99. So, buying the L2D seems like the better cost option if I want both options. - ..... If I have it figured out right in my head (?????).

I am going to look into it.

I like options! <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/thumbup.gif" alt="" />