I liked the Bama Clay Warden, which I think was normal thickness -- I recall that you said the green was a fatty. I also seem to remember that after looking at the Hacks, you started comparing them against getting another SAR5.
In my opinion, you made the right decision by going for that FSH. I REALLY like the feel of the hand-shaped handles on my Bama Clay NMSFNO, but I'm still second-guessing myself about whether I should have gotten the other hand-shaped Micarta FSH instead.