Last week I began looking for Bourbon, specifically Van Winkle Bourbon, based on a thread on the Busse Combat BladeForums sub-forum. In ignorance of the price, my thoughts were to try a bottle of Pappy Van Winkle (23 year old). When we went to the Liquor Barn, I found that they had no Van Winkle in stock.
I decided to get a bottle of Four Roses (small batch because its description was more appealing to me than the single barrel) because more than one local Bourbon aficionado has sung its praises. I also bought a bottle of Bernheim small batch wheat whiskey (I'm not sure why, but its description also appealed to me) and a bottle of Old Overholt rye whiskey (plus a couple cases of Octoberfest beer, one Spaten and one Sam Adams, but that's a different story). Old Overholt was a strange choice in that it's quite cheap (just over $12/liter); however, I'd read good things about it online and at that price it wasn't much of a risk.
I haven't opened the Four Roses or Bernheim yet, but I've drunk much of the Old Overholt (mixed about 1/3 spring water to 2/3 whiskey, I've found that it helps me fall asleep when I've had trouble sleeping otherwise) and have been very pleasantly surprised with it. You won't impress anyone as a big spender with it, but it's a rather smooth, very palatable drink.
Today, I continued the Van Winkle quest with more success. I found a local liquor store named "The Keg" (
http://www.kegliquors.com/) that had one bottle of 10 YO Van Winkle for $36.99 which I bought. They also had a bottle of 23 YO Pappy, but wanted $300 for it, which is too rich for me. When I went grocery shopping at Kroger, I strolled through their liquor isle and noticed that they had a couple bottles of Jack Daniels single barrel (Tennessee whiskey) on closeout for just under $30 a bottle, so I bought them on impulse. Finally, on the way home, I decided to stop at another local liquor store, and scored their only bottle of Van Winkle Special Reserve 12 YO "Lot B". It was $52.99, but I was quite happy to find it as that's a more difficult to find spirit. They also had a $300 bottle of Pappy; I suspect that, like JWB, it's a spirit I'll never taste.
The owner of The Keg told me that he used to be able to get a cases of Van Winkle, but last season he only received 8 bottles. He also said that he expects the Fall delivery in about three weeks, so I can check back then. So, for a fellow who doesn't usually drink much, I find myself building up quite a liquor cabinet.