Hi Nick,

Go to Ordawg's "Personal SY Inventory" thread.
Scroll down until you see Andy Wayne's picture post. It's about 1/2 way
down the first page of the thread.
Counting from the left hand side (not counting the JYD coin) the Mud Puppy
is 9th one in. Light handle, right between a HCLE on the left and a SS4 on
the right.
It has mudder handles like the SS4 beside it, but light colored.

I don't have one myself, but when you put it next to the SS4 (in the picture),
they sure look similar.