Thanks to everyone for their input so far...

@bld522: the Ash-1 is nice, but too big for an edc for my tastes.

@reconseed: your posts are what started me looking at the SD.

@pitman and Paul the Brit: I am not offended, I asked for opinions, good or bad.

@ Kraz

i will have to re-look at the ADs and Game Wardens...


I agree. If it was a normal Wharncliffe, It would be a no-brainer. The reverse curve concerns me for usability. I have seen a post where someone had straitened the blade, but I have neither the skill or inclination.


Ultimately, I agree, but there is a lot of experience and knowledge that I value here in the Yard.

@rooikat: the late night viewing is what keeps almost getting me in trouble. Just am not 100% on the blade shape.

@ Paul the Brit and Private Klink: I agree there are NO inexpensive Busse blades, but some are more out of my price range than others....

@bodhi: it does seem to be a love it or hate it blade...

I look forward to reading more...

...like i said man.. you will have to take the plunge on 1 or the other. i think you will be better pleased if you go with the Scotch Dispenser.. Just my thoughts <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

At Knob Creek, I asked about the Sus Scrofa -- one of the folks said that they have a friend who does leather work and loves it for cutting patterns. Basically, it's a Wharncliffe/Hawkbill hybrid that is probably ideal for certain specialized tasks. If you cut line or you're an emergency responder who may need to slice through harness belt material, it's probably a great tool. Perhaps if you need to cut hoses or shape gaskets it could be just what you're looking for, but I ended up canceling my order because I couldn't convince myself that I had a need for one.

I have a few ADs and BADs, but no Busse Combat Wardens -- I didn't like their handle. I like the AD style, but if I was currently looking into an EDC, I'd go for the Mud Puppy (I fully intend to buy a few). As far as Busse Combat EDCs, I'd recommend a BAD if you can find one, although you'll spend more than for 3 Mud Puppies. If you want INFI, but don't require that it be a Busse Combat, then I'd search for an SS4 -- they can sometimes be had for about $200. The Street Scrapper 4 is a favorite with just about everybody who's ever held one.

between the 2 you are looking at - hands down go with the SD <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> Rainwalker makes an absolutely PERFECT leather sheath that ride high and tight for the scotch dispenser too! I carry mine everywhere. <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> let me know when and what you get man.

I wasn't crazy about the SS or the SD, but I gave the SD a try because I knew I would need it. I prefer my Bad Warden (fancy Skelly Warden), I EDC it every day, and have ever since I got it. If I remember correctly it was my first Busse Combat Blade.

this is "the Guy" when it comes to leather <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/bowdown.gif" alt="" />

Well, I finally broke down and bought a Sus Scrofa (Satin [.170] Blue/Black G-10). I saw it on the BladeForums Exchange and kept going back to it; the price dropped enough that I just couldn't resist anymore. I hope it'll grow on me -- I think that's one of the best SS configurations.

Anyone have a pic of the Scotch Dispenser?

The grip design is literally based on the shape of a scotch tape dispenser.

Thanks Jim, pretty cool looking knive/necker.

SS? only SS I can think of is Sus Scrofa or snakeskin. what exactly did you score?

i'm beenreally tempted to get both as long as they've been in the store...