Scrap Yard Discussion Forums

Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
My S5 backpacking review...now with PICS!!! #357184 07/21/09 06:19 AM
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 152
D
damon Offline OP
Mutt
OP Offline
Mutt
D
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 152
Ever since the initial picture release of the S5 I have been giddy for this knife to come out. Over the last 6 or so years, my battle rat has served me faithfully as my go-to camp knife (it has the scars to prove it), but over the years I have gotten older, fatter, and weaker and have constantly been looking for places to shave the weight off my pack…a 9.5” long, .25” thick blade just really doesn’t fit into that goal <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif" alt="" />. Never the less, this last Fri/Sat I was finally able to get “out there” and see just how well the S5 fit into its perspective role as my new “favorite (backpacking) knife.”

Initial impressions:

Res-c and SR101!!!!! Together again WITH a thin blade, woooo-hooooooo!

Love the color combo! I originally picked out the sage/green thinking that while it might not look the best, it would however best match my forthcoming ACUs that I hope to get issued (long story there). However, upon arrival the handles looked like a much more subdued, grey-green than what the initial pictures looked like on my monitor. Fearing that I might never use the blade due to is attractiveness, I quickly put a 2x4 in my shop vice and hacked away until I marred the finish just enough to void the “mint condish” look.

[img][image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04665.jpg[/img][/image]

The one design issue that I was a bit skeptical about was the square choil and to be honest, now that I have the blade in hand, I have to say that I like it quite a bit less than the choil on my other Bussekin blades. To me, the choil seems to be just a bit too small to let my finger “know” not to move forward, yet it does take up what would be a considerable amount of edge that would be great for up close work should I be using a traditional grip on the handle.

As far as weight is concerned, this seems to me to be a really light knife for its blade length (yet another advantage of the res-c over slab handles). I don’t have the quiver of others, but comparing it to my Desert Jack and SAR 5 is night and day. For me, this is both a blessing and a curse as I need something significantly easier to carry than the battle rat, but still want to be able to do some light chopping on the trail. However, I really like the balance. I know some feel it is a bit too blade heavy, I personally do not feel any discomfort what so ever, but again that might be due to what I am used to using. If anything, I wish that it was a bit more blade heavy as I think that would add to its ability to chop, but maybe I am missing something that others are seeing here. Quick shot of my 5inch(ish) blades

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04664.jpg[/img][/image]


How to carry the S5?

Unlike most here, I’m a cheapskate. As such, I will try to Mickey Mouse almost anything myself rather than shell out the cash to have someone else do it right. Therefore, I have slapped together pretty poor excuses for kydex sheaths for most of my blades. The reason why I include this in my review is because in my limited experience, the overall weight of the blade, and the balance affects how comfortable the knife is in my pathetic attempts at sheaths. For a knife in this range, I want something that I can carry cross draw. This may be silly to some but quick access to my blade gives me some reassurance when I am hiking in bear and mtn lion country and for me, the traditional side/kidney carry is too slow and awkward and does not work well for me when I am wearing my pack. With that being said, if the blade is too heavy overall, or one that is especially handle heavy like my SAR 5, the rig is either not comfortable, or requires the use of a more substantial pants belt which is the last thing I personally want around my waist under my pack’s waist belt. All this to say, the light weight, and slightly blade heavy balance of the S5 lends itself to an almost perfect ride for me and my otherwise asinine requirements for a “wearable” hiking knife.

--------Here is the difference between the S% and SAR5. Notice the Wight of the SAR5 requires a bit higher cant, which then gets in the way of my buckle and the blade heavy weight also tends to want to roll forward the handle of the SAR5.

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04700.jpg[/img][/image]

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04702.jpg[/img][/image]

bird's eye view shows "the roll"

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04703.jpg[/img][/image]


In the field:

shots along the way and at the lake 7 miles in:

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04662.jpg[/img][/image]

(if you close one eye, squint real hard, and tilt your head 180* to the left, you can just make out a small doe in the scrub brush)

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04663.jpg[/img][/image]

view from our campsite

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04660.jpg[/img][/image]

Sorry for the lack of action picks here…turns out taking photos of yourself chopping wood, chopping wood, and swatting mosquitoes simultaneously is about three tasks too many for someone like me to handle.

The S5 was primarily put to work doing random camp tasks. This weekend, that meant light chopping, splitting firewood, and opening up various food packages. FWIW, I usually bring four or five blades with me: my SAK trekker, my battle rat, the Ritter griptillain, the mini sak on my keychain and some other random knives from fillet blades to a kurk or the becker necker…oh yeah, and not counting the blade on the multitool. However, on this trip I tried to exercise some personal restraint and limited myself to only the S5, which I figured would really make me see just how well it would fit the bill of my ultimate backpacking knife.

The results:

Chopping- well, no surprise, it didn’t quite have the reach or efficiency of the Battle Rat, but for my purposes I thought it did quite well. I had to work a bit more, but the overall “carry-a-bility” was worth it for me. I didn’t breeze through several inch diameter standing deadwood, but it did fine limbing a few blown over pine trees, as smaller diameter “squaw wood” is typically what we burn anyway.

Batoning- The S5 performed WAY better here than I thought it would. Not sure why, but it slid though wood in a remarkable way. My buddy had a similarly sized/shaped/sharpened blade and the S5 completely blew it away in this category. I have no real understanding of why this is, all I know is that I was beyond pleasantly surprised. One other thing I should note, this is a fundamental test for me as it is probably my most important function of a jack-of-all-trades blade because I see it as what allows me to forego the traditional hatchet or big chopper and still be able to provide reasonable firewood. I should add here that the sage blade coating on the S5 seems more durable than that on my battle rat or howling rat. Not sure why that would be, just the impression that I am getting so far.

--------These have been added since the trip…less bugs in the backyard <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />
Here is a piece of wood that replicates about the largest sized stuff that we would come across. I think that these pics do a good job of showing the relative size between the (top to bottom) the SS4, Howling Rat, and S5. I tried to stick ‘em with about the same amount of sharpened edge relative to the choil to show the vastly greater batoning ability of the S5. The SS4 and HR are good knives, but IMO/IME a large choil can really hurt you batoning as it seems for me to get hung up on the wood. The length of blade/ size of choil of the HR I would say would limit the effective batoning by a solid 1.5 inches compared to the S5.

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04708.jpg[/img][/image]

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04709.jpg[/img][/image]


-----here the SAR5 takes over for the HR. Even though the edge length of the SAR and S5 is almost identical, you can see how much difference a choil makes for this task. The SAR5 might be able to take an additional 1/2 inch in diameter piece of wood over the S5

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04711.jpg[/img][/image]




Random “woodcraft”- this comprised of finding a stick and trying to fashion a fishing spear of some kind. The blade performed well, kept its edge more than well enough after the above firecraft to make a hideous spear. I am confident that it (the knife) was pointy enough and sharp enough to do whatever I could ask of it. I should also note here that the square choil was not nearly as bad as my initial impressions would have lead me to believe. When I actually did use it, I didn’t feel any less comfort or sense of security than the “traditional” rounded choils, I was very happy to be proven wrong here. If I had my choice I think I would still likely opt for the rounded choil (unless there is an advantage to the square one that I am ignorant of), but the current choil is very functional for me. Also, while everyone agrees that it is rather subjective, the thumb ramp fits my little girl hands perfect.


----again, done in the backyard... some snap cutting baby Aspen. The SAR and S5 performed equally well here (and the HR better than I thought):

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04712.jpg[/img][/image]

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04713.jpg[/img][/image]


Prying- This is another area where the S5 really shined. At one point at our campsite, there was the remainder of a tree stump that needed to be “trimmed” by about four inches. This was accomplished quite easily by batoning the blade into parts of the stump and then prying it out bit by bit…took less time and effort than if I had used a saw (which I didn’t have anyway). Needless to say, the “thin” blade wasn’t phased in the least by my torqueing and I am really happy that Dan and the crew stayed away from quarter inch stock for this knife as its current specs are more than strong enough (or is it tough enough?) for my uses.

Carry:
As expected, this blade was a joy to carry. Light enough that it rode perfectly without a belt. I never felt it jabbing into me as we scrambled around boulders and I never got the sense that it was weighing down my shorts. After we set up camp we took off to explore the far side of the lake a bit and I know that I would have never taken a larger knife with me. However the S5 was virtually unnoticeable yet its presence did allow me the opportunity to NOT act my age, fashion a spear and likely give several rainbow trout a good laugh at the balding old guy with the pointy stick.
-----And an other shot of the lake, we did some boulder scrambling on the left side. LOTS of 12 inch or so rainbow trout along the shoreline (maybe two feet out). Never seem anything like it for an alpine lake.

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04661.jpg[/img][/image]


Conclusion:
The S5 is darn near my new favorite (backpacking) knife (I only need a few more nights out to confirm its superiority). It carries very well, it does a great job around the camp, and it is significantly more than tough enough/strong enough to do anything that I can see myself asking of it. It is not the best chopper, but if getting through mass amounts of wood was the absolute end-all determination of my pack list, my buddy’s Husqvarna would get the nod anyway. While I might like to see a few things tweaked a tinny bit (maybe a bit wider blade to give it a smidge more chopping ability); for my general, do it yourself, carry it yourself, jack-of-all-trades camp knife, the S5 so far has exceeded my high expectations and once again, I am grateful to have the SR101/res-c combo alive!



-----oh yeah, duct tape is great stuff, but it still doesn't put the skin back on after it has been rubbed raw by lack of socks;)

[img]http://[image]http://i7.photobucket.com/albums/y258/damonstage/backpacking%20and%20knife%20review/DSC04658.jpg[/img][/image]

Last edited by damon; 07/23/09 02:13 PM.
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: damon] #357185 07/21/09 07:30 AM
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 46,605
Private Klink Online Content
Junk Yard Dog
Online Content
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 46,605
Nice review - looking forward to pics! <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/wink.gif" alt="" /> <img src="/ubbthreads/images/graemlins/grin.gif" alt="" />


Junk Yard Dog #1
Moderator/Leader of the Pack
Good night Mrs. B, wherever you are!
Long Live the Brotherhood of the Yard!
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: Private Klink] #357186 07/21/09 07:48 AM
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,103
RN Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,103
Thanks for putting all the time into this...great write up!


JYD #109
"I came here for the knives and stayed for the people."
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: RN] #357187 07/21/09 07:49 AM
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,103
RN Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: May 2008
Posts: 4,103
I love my Howling Rat as a small woods knife. How did they compare?


JYD #109
"I came here for the knives and stayed for the people."
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: RN] #357188 07/21/09 08:09 AM
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,319
S
Sigfest Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
S
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 1,319
Thanks for your review. Lots of good observations.


JYD #96 STILL looking for coin #96..
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: Sigfest] #357189 07/21/09 09:49 AM
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 4,654
MustardMan Offline
Permanently banned
Offline
Permanently banned
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 4,654
That's an awesome write-up. The s5 is a pretty dang handy little blade. I do agree about the square choil though - if given the choice, I would opt for round, or better yet, no choil at all.

Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: MustardMan] #357190 07/21/09 12:35 PM
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 7,861
J33psr0ck Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Mar 2007
Posts: 7,861
Great review. I too find myself carrying smaller fixed blades when I am hiking. I can't wait to try out the S5 in the hills. It's been way too hot out here to go running amuck in the desert so hopefully soon.


JYD # 19
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: MustardMan] #357191 07/21/09 12:39 PM
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,729
Gambit Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 1,729
Thanks for the review, good stuff.


JYD #73 Chance favors the prepared mind.
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: Gambit] #357192 07/21/09 02:49 PM
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,943
KnifeGuy Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Jan 2007
Posts: 2,943
Great review and I agree with pretty much all your points.

With a few tweeks to the choil, the front of the Res-C and personally I removed my ramp, but I can appreciate where some might like it. I think it is as well placed a thumb ramps as most knives, but I do slightly prefer the RMD's ramp.

For me, I prefer no ramp.

For me, the choil really needed rounded and enlarged up into the guard a bit.

As it was, my index finger barely even fits and I think it is too prone to nick fingers. I recommend people dulling that edge corner at the ricasso. But, enlarging and rounding feels a LOT better IMO.

.


JYD #39 I prefer "SATIN" blades!!!
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: KnifeGuy] #357193 07/21/09 03:04 PM
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,276
Sethrotull Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 4,276
Thanks for the great review. Looking to put mine to the test soon.


JYD #100
Dog, Hog, Rat it's all Bussekin
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: Sethrotull] #357194 07/21/09 03:42 PM
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 332
archangel Offline
Mongrel
Offline
Mongrel
Joined: Apr 2009
Posts: 332
I've got the same sage/green coming. I like the colors for camo and military purposes. I would love to have an International orange S5.......and a S7 heavier duty S5. This blade WOULD replace ALL my others as my primary cutter.


(archangel) instrument of Gods wrath
Re: My S5 backpacking review [Re: damon] #357195 07/21/09 04:02 PM
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 14,586
Horn Dog Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Offline
Junk Yard Dog
Joined: Feb 2007
Posts: 14,586
I agree with your review of the S5, damon. I did some serious baton work with mine today, splitting gnarly Red Bay which is dying all over my yard. I must have 20 of them. Looks like lots of firewood for this Fall's oyster roasts.
[Linked Image from i173.photobucket.com]
[Linked Image from i173.photobucket.com]
[Linked Image from i173.photobucket.com]


Horned, dangerous, and off my medication.
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3