I think the scrapper 5 will go for a bit more than the dumpster mutt will. Scrapper 5 tends to be a 150ish dollar knife brand new (sometimes you see em for 130 or so but they usually go almost immediately at that price) and the dumpster mutt would probably be more like a 120ish dollar knife new.

I'd say it depends on how "used" each one was.

Just my .02, others may have a different opinion.