P tip sounds good. The reason I went with the spec is I want a knife that can still be handy for light tasks such as skinning. Also for a fighting utility I see to much weight means less control in the movement of the knife due to inertia.
My blade still has the ability to reach all vital organs for CQB but will still be short enough to wear vertically or horizontally on a tac vest in a pinch can be a IWB or belt knife. Strapped to calf