Quote
Dude, WTF you talking about?

Remember the D2 knives from Swamp Rat? They were tough as hell and were given quite a beating and survived. They dented rather than chipped and because they were still D2 they had really good edge retention. SRKW 154cm's heat treat shouldn't be any different.

Remember that D2 has much worse toughness than 154cm. If I had a choice for a large chopper with D2 or 154cm I would go 154cm.

Also, Mercworx use 154cm on most of their knives. They're heat treated softer for toughness and can also take quite a beating with little chipping (though for their price I think an FFBM would be beyond par).

I agree with you in that I'm not a fan of 154cm but when something comes from the Swamp, Yard, or Pit, it must be good.

first of all, don't swear at me

You're right that heat treatment will make a difference, but you also should remember that the knives that failed us in the field have all been 154cm. This sort of experience is not something that inspires confidence.

In respect to mercworx, very little testing has been on those knives to determine whether or not they can put their money where their mouth is. To me, they seem to be a more tastefully designed version of Dark Ops Knives, minus the terrible advertising. Just because they're expensive, doesn't mean they're worth the money.

My main argument with 154cm in SR knives is that I believe that the switch to stainless is unnecessary and sacrifices too much. I personally believe the difference between coated and uncoated blades in terms of efficiency is negligible, so there is little need for a satin-finished steel. Furthermore, seeing as the banner of SR's website reads "Ambassadors of American spirit and toughness", I don't think they should drop an extremely tough AND edge-holding steel from production in favor of a steel thats only real advantage is its stainlessness.

If they can prove that a H. Carry is just as tough as the nearly identical HRLM, I'll be happy to accept it. Until then, I will continue to view 154cm as a folder steel, not suited for hard use.


Have you hugged your camp knife today?