they're all nine out of ten anyway, right? the two percent differences in my eyes are insignificant. beside there are many factors ignored by those statistics. who stops firing after one shot? how do they really know how many times a single shot failed? any time a single shot failed, and it's possible many shots failed, that data never makes it to the study. go with your gut and keep it simple, bigger holes. don't get me started on hyprostatic shock.
I do agree with you though - I don't carry and have never fired the .357 sig, but I've heard great thigs about it. I have my 9mm as my OD/EDC because I wanted 10 rounds in a small frame. I go with the 1911 as a full size just because it is tried and true, I like .45ACP, and it is pretty accurate. I've also got some Wilson Combat upgrades on it... and it just looks good on the hip! I carried a Glock 22 (.40) for a couple of years and really liked it as well.
