You guys left out some of the most popular models ever, the SS4, BAD, CABS, and RMD
First off, what is the handle material and color of your Culti? That looks nearly perfect for her, but I am slightly colorblind, so I can't tell if it's the hue of green I would want. Nevertheless, it looks perfect! Great looking knife you have there!
I considered the HRLM, RMD, BAD, and CABs. I have handled and own (or have owned them all). While they are some of the best, the only one I would consider for her would be the CABS and I like some of the other options better.
I showed her my BAD and although the handles were perfect, the spear point blade shape was a turn off. She would likely grow to love it, so it is definitely an option once she's more comfortable around knives.
I personally don't like the HOG MUK handles very much, but the drop point hunter would otherwise be perfect! Now if Jerry were to finally release the long awaited MINI MUK!!!! I think we'd have a clear winner:
I hadn't even thought about the SS4, having never owned or handled one. I think it looks pretty great. I would definitely strip it, and would prefer a version with tan or muddy handles (never seen one,) so it would probably take eternity to find
We are planning our first trip soon, so what I'm going to do is have someone, possibly a friend, add stabilized turquoise ambrosia handles to a Swamp Warden, or possibly Scrapivore. I'm going to let her use that for the first trip, along with my BASIC 4 LE and others. I think she will really like the custom scales and the fact that I picked out handles with her favorite color and had it made for her.
I have seen plenty of Scrapivore handle jobs, but cannot seem to find any examples of Wardens. If anyone has pictures or a link to a Warden that has had a nice handle job, please post it.
ETA: found what I think is an awesome looking Swamp Warden handle job. This would be perfect with the turquoise stabilized ambrosia and mosaic pins: