I've never really been a shotgun guy either. I have a total of 4, the nicest of which is a Remington Sportsman 48B in 20ga that a dying friend gave to me. His grandfather put a lot of rounds through it upland bird hunting in California. A similar one could be found for about $300 if you looked hard enough. It's a nice shooting gun.

I also have an old single shot Rossi 20ga that my dad used when he was growing up in Oklahoma. It's a total beater.